Skincare: Clinique Dramatically Different Moisturizer Versus Neutrogena Illuminating Whip Moisturizer

My mom told my sister and I several things about our skin when we were young. My sister had rather oily skin. Mine was extremely dry. One thing she said to my sister when she was a teenager was, “You might be having problems with pimples now, but when you girls are older, you will not age as quickly as your sister.” That may have made my sister feel better, but it made me feel like the pits.

I did make some decisions about my skin because of my mom’s words way back then. I decided to try to stay as young as possible, by using good products and caring for this dry skin properly. Today at 50, I still strive for a smooth, soft face. Clinique gives me that.

I have been using Clinique’s 3-Step Skin Care Program for about 20 years. Not only does this cleanse, but also it exfoliates my skin. The Clarifying lotion helps with this after I wash with their facial soap. Clinique’s Dramatically Different Moisturizing Lotion is the icing on the cake. It soaks into my face and makes it feel as soft as a baby. It is really the key for me.

About a year ago, I decided to save some money. Who knows why? I am working toward paying for my son’s college among many other things. I ran out of my Clinique and decided to buy something less expensive. I bought Neutrogena Illuminating Whip Moisturizer, Along with it, I bought their other skin care products, for my skin. I purchased the Deep Clean Cream Cleanser, and even some Anti-Aging Crème. I wanted and must have a good moistuizer.

I don’t really know why I chose Neutrogena. I was walking down the aisle of the store and trying to decide which one to choose. This is not a very practical way to choose your moisturizers and skin care regimen. The blue container kind of just popped out from the rest. I liked the packaging. It looked fresh and clean to me with the white lettering. The advertising people did a really good job designing the packaging. I bought it and took it home thinking I would be saving money and helping my face.

I began to put water on my face to clean with the Deep Clean Cream Cleanser. When I took it off with the water, I felt that I was a little “too clean” or something. My face was tight and dry. I was hoping the moisturizer was going to take the feeling away. I put the Neutrogena Illuminating Whip Moisturizer all over my face. It felt OK. An hour later, my face felt dry again. I reapplied the Neutrogena Illuminating Whip Moisturizer. My face felt a little sticky but not soft.

I did continue to use these products because I wanted to give them a fair chance. After three weeks, I began to have little bumps under my eyes. I stopped applying the moisturizer close to my eyes and the bumps faded. When I squeezed the last drop out of the Neutrogena Illuminating Whip Moisturizer (I do not know what was whipped into this moisturizer), I went as quickly as my little car would take me to get some more Clinique 3-Step Skin Care Program.

I found my yellow bottle of lotion with the pump at the Clinique display in Belk. I even got it on sale. That was unexpected. Clinique is known for giving tote bags or makeup bags, and I got one each of those. With packages in tow, I was headed home.

I quickly washed my face with their facial soap. This time I decided to try the liquid facial soap. It was just as wonderful as the bar soap. The bar has no smell, and the liquid has a slight smell; however, it was the same clean soft feeling on my face. The Clarifying lotion exfoliated gently, yet my skin still did not feel dry. I was ready for the Clinique Dramatically Different Moisturizing Lotion. I applied it to my skin and it slowly sank in. It seemed as if my skin was smiling. That soft, supple feeling was back once more.

I made myself a promise. I would never run out of my Clinique Dramatically Different Moisturizer again. It was simply not worth it.

This is the truth. The next day, two of my co-workers asked me if I had a new haircut or if I was wearing new makeup. They all know I only wear eye makeup. They asked if I had a facial. I smiled and said no. They said I looked really good that day. I knew it was just my face because it finally had the moisture it had been lacking from Neutrogena. Moisturizer is the key to healthy, beautiful skin…even at 50.

It is worth the extra money. We only have one face, right?

Leave a Reply